_edited.png)
3.5
Seeking Divergent Thinking
Submitted by Shannon Wheatley Hartman
This activity describes how to systematically examine a topic from a multi-dimensional approach. It encourages divergent thinking by asking participants to generate different questions and viewpoints about a single area of concern, deepening appreciation for complexity.
Learning Goals
Practice examining an issue from multiple perspectives and dimensions.
Practice crafting discussion questions that examine different dimensions of a topic.
Instructions
Set Up: Prepare for the Activity
Select a broad issue that is important or pressing for the group (i.e. Housing, Food Security, Climate Change, AI, etc.).
Share the Surrounding the Topic Diagram on the board, screen, or as a handout. Place the topic at the center.
Share the Crafting Discussion Questions Worksheet.
Begin by introducing the learning goals of this activity.
Step One: Generate Possible Dimensions (5 min)
As a full group, invite participants to generate a list of dimensions that affect or are affected by this topic. Dimensions tend to be broad categories like governance, technology, religion/spirituality, culture, law/ethics, politics, psychology, arts, media, economics, environment, etc.
Sample dimensions are included in the Surrounding the Topic Diagram. Use or replace these. As a group, populate all external circles of the diagram with different but relevant dimensions.
Step Two: Craft Discussion Questions (10 min)
In pairs, ask participants to craft open ended questions for each dimension. Explain that the questions are to be designed for a discussion group. Instruct them to record these questions in the Crafting Discussion Questions Worksheet.
The questions should be open-ended (avoiding yes/no answers).
Participants should try to briefly explain the rationale for this question.
Once teams have multiple questions, ask them to consider the strategic ordering of questions and record their thoughts in the first column.
Step Three: Discuss Questions in Small Groups (25 min)
Return to the full group or create small discussion groups (6-8 ppl), and begin discussing the topic.
Ask for a volunteer to share their first question. Discuss the question.
As the discussion unfolds, invite another participant to share a question that explores a new dimension.
The discussion group may only have enough time to discuss 2-3 questions. Instruct them that it is better to focus on a couple of dimensions of the topic and not try to discuss all dimensions or questions.
Remind them that crafting discussion questions help them to mentally prepare for the discussion, even if they don’t get a chance to share their questions.
Step Four: Debrief as a Full Group (10 min)
Would anyone like to share a favorite discussion question that they weren’t able to introduce during the discussion?
What does the exercise of “surrounding the topic” do? How did new or less expected dimensions open up the discussion?
How did you experience crafting questions? How did this help you prepare for our discussion?
How do you think the discussion would have gone today if we did not surround the topic or prepare multiple discussion questions in advance?
TIME
50
min
MODULE
Critical Collaboration
This activity can be completed by any discussion group.
This activity can be easily modified for asynchronous learning. See Sample Asynchronous Certificate Program Design to illustrate sample sequencing.
This activity is suitable for professional or more formal learning environments.
This activity can be used to support facilitation skills. See Sample Facilitation Certificate Program Design to illustrate sample sequencing.
Tell us what you think. Rate and review this activity:
Have any helpful suggestions or modifications for this activity?
Share them in the comments below!
0 Comments
YD
December 3, 2022 at 2:39:23 AM
Activity 5.4 uses the fun method of role playing and builds on other activities to help participants develop questions and practice gathering information to collaborate effectively with communities as partners. This activity involves working together in small groups and as a large group. It also includes multiple additional resources for participants to continue learning methods and skills to build community partnerships.
YD
December 3, 2022 at 2:39:00 AM
Activity 1.8 provides a very useful survey to gather information on and help support participants' different discussion styles and needs, exploring various areas like preferences for group size, ways of participating in discussions, any fears relating to discussions, etc.
YD
December 3, 2022 at 2:34:46 AM
Activity 5.8 further explores direct democracy by proposing the idea of "legislative juries" to improve the current initiative process through collaboration and deliberation. This activity uses role playing to have participants practice deliberation as part of a mock legislative jury to craft ballot initiatives on a given issue.
YD
December 3, 2022 at 2:27:35 AM
Activity 5.7 uses a fun and tactile activity like building LEGOs to explore the effects of coming together to colloborate and discuss, while also participating together in another physical activity.
YD
December 3, 2022 at 2:22:49 AM
Activity 5.6 uses memes and futuristic zombie scenarios to develop ways to change people's minds, while exploring various aspects of the methods used to change minds, like assumptions behind ideas, sticking to the facts versus stretching the truth, appealing to emotions etc.
YD
December 3, 2022 at 2:16:44 AM
Activity 5.5 uses a fun and visual/craft activity to help participants explore the many different types of knowledge, how they are valued, and the role/importance of each type of knowledge in their own lives.
YD
December 3, 2022 at 2:11:54 AM
Activity 5.3 gives participants to use writing, drawing, and/or speaking to share and discuss the various communities they belong to and/or feel excluded from, the various aspects that define community, as well as the practices of inclusion or exclusion and power distribution in these communities.
YD
December 3, 2022 at 2:07:26 AM
Activity 5.2 introduces four categories of stakeholders and multiple prompts to help participants work together in small and large groups to create comprehensive list of stakeholders, including those who are marginalized or not as obvious, for a given issue.
YD
December 3, 2022 at 2:04:00 AM
Activity 5.1 uses gamification by having participants play the Civics Topics Sweet Sixteen Competition to identify their issues they are passionate about both as individuals and as a group.
YD
December 3, 2022 at 2:01:34 AM
Activity 4.9 uses both lighthearted and serious characters, topics, and dialogue to help participants practice viewing an issue from the perspective of multiple people/characters and explain their thought processes and rationale for the choices they think these people will make in a given situation.