Instructions

Set Up: Prepare for the Activity

Prepare to record the discussion on a white board, flip chart, or Google Jamboard.

Begin by introducing the learning goals of this activity.

Step One: Individually Reflect on Positive Collaboration Characteristics (5 min)

Introduce the following prompts. Allow five minutes of silent reflection and writing before inviting participants to share their answers.

• Think back to a time when you had a positive collaborative experience. Really try to remember a specific example. Where were you? Why were you collaborating?

• Take a moment to remember it. If you have a piece of paper, jot down a few descriptive words. Why did it work well? What made it a positive collaborative experience?

• What are the traits or characteristics of a positive collaborative experience?

Step Two: Share Positive Collaboration Characteristics (10 min)

Once participants have had a few minutes to reflect, ask the group to share their positive collaboration traits or characteristics. Try to record the answers thematically, if possible. Do not engage in discussion or explanation of traits. Generate a broad list of positive attributes.

Step Three: Share Negative Collaboration Characteristics (10 min)

Next, using a slightly expedited process, invite participants to think back to a negative collaborative discussion experience:

• Why was it bad? What are some characteristics of negative collaboration?

• What should be avoided when collaborating with others?

Invite participants to think for a couple of minutes and then share 2-3 characteristics of a negative collaborative experience. Record as before.

Step Four (optional): Rank Top 5 Positive and Negative Collaboration Attributes (20 min)

In pairs or small groups, invite participants to review the lists and identify at least 5 common attributes associated with successful collaboration. Discuss their importance and rank them. For example:

• Diversity of perspective

• Trust and respect within the group

• Responsiveness to team members

• Familiarity

• Playfulness

Repeat this process for negative collaborative experiences.

Step Five: Debrief as a Full Group (15 min)

Invite participants to review the full lists on the white board or the jamboard. Discuss what collaboration means to the full group:

• What are some common observations? Do themes or schemes of analysis emerge from these lists?

• Which attributes are most likely to undermine the success of collaboration?

• Which attributes would make for the most ideal discussion environment?

• Who is responsible for successful collaboration?

• How do we create a positive collaborative experience?